Two Afrobeats Stars Face Backlash After Comments About Not Identifying as Black

 Two Afrobeats Stars Face Backlash After Comments About Not Identifying as Black

In the ever-expanding world of Afrobeats, artists are reaching global audiences at unprecedented levels. But with rising fame also comes heightened scrutiny. In recent years, two major Afrobeats artists have faced significant backlash—particularly from African Americans—after making statements or taking actions that suggested they do not identify as Black, or that distanced themselves from Black identity in the diaspora.

These moments caused cultural tension, sparked heated debates across social media, and opened discussions about how Africans and African Americans understand race, identity, and shared history.

1. Burna Boy: “Being African Is Different from Being Black”

Burna Boy, often celebrated for promoting African pride and pan-African themes, shocked many listeners when he made remarks implying that African Americans lacked cultural grounding and that being “Black” is a Western construct.

While his intention may have been to highlight the difference between race in America and ethnicity in Africa, many African Americans interpreted his comments as dismissive of their lived experiences. Critics argued that his stance minimized centuries of racial trauma in the U.S. and suggested that Africans were somehow separate from the global Black identity.

This tension resurfaced when videos surfaced online showing Burna Boy distancing himself from being labeled “Black” in the Western sense, emphasizing instead that he is “African.” For many fans in the diaspora, it felt like a rejection.

Backlash

African American fans voiced frustration, saying:

• He benefited from Black American support but refused to recognize the shared identity.

• His comments reinforced harmful divisions between Africans and African Americans.

• He was perpetuating the idea that Africans stand above or apart from the struggles of Black people globally.

The controversy sparked think-pieces, TikTok debates, and long conversations on Twitter/X about whether global success has pressured some African artists to distance themselves from Blackness to appeal to wider markets.

2. Tyla: “I’m Not Black—I'm Coloured in South Africa”

South African pop and Afrobeats fusion artist Tyla also found herself in the center of a cultural storm after clarifying that she identifies as “Coloured” rather than Black—reflecting South Africa’s unique racial classifications shaped by apartheid.

Tyla explained that in South Africa, “Coloured” is a distinct cultural and ethnic identity, not a slur, and that she did not grow up identifying as Black in the U.S. sense. While this was a statement of cultural fact, it sparked immediate backlash among African American audiences.

Backlash

Many African Americans felt her comments were disheartening because:

• They interpreted her statement as a distancing from Black identity, especially once she gained global attention.

• They felt her explanation failed to acknowledge that outside South Africa, she benefits from being perceived as a Black woman.

• The timing coincided with her rising fame in the U.S., making some fans feel used or dismissed.

Social media reactions varied widely, with some defending her cultural identity while others accused her of erasing her connection to Blackness.

A Growing Divide—or an Opportunity for Dialogue?

The backlash against Burna Boy and Tyla reflects more than celebrity drama—it highlights deep, long-standing tensions between Africans and African Americans over identity, race, and history.

Key issues raised include:

• Different definitions of “Black”
  In Africa, identity often centers on ethnicity and nationality—not race.
  In America, race is central to daily life and social experience.

• Cultural misunderstandings
  What’s normal in one society may be offensive in another.

• Shared history, but different realities
  While African Americans face systemic racism rooted in slavery and segregation, Africans often navigate identity through tribal and national lenses.

Despite the conflicts, many argue these conversations are necessary. The global rise of Afrobeats has brought Africa and the diaspora closer than ever—making it even more important to bridge cultural gaps with empathy and understanding.

Where Do We Go From Here?

Both Burna Boy and Tyla continue to thrive musically. However, their controversies serve as reminders that global platforms carry global responsibilities. Artists who reach diverse audiences must navigate identity with sensitivity, awareness, and openness to difficult conversations.

At the same time, the diaspora community is reexamining what it means to be Black worldwide—and how culture, history, and geography shape identity in powerful ways.

---